Support Center / Therapies & Operation / For Chronic Back Pain, Is a Walk-In Tub or Deep Soaking Whirlpool Better?
Back to Therapies & Operation

For Chronic Back Pain, Is a Walk-In Tub or Deep Soaking Whirlpool Better?

You do not have to choose between the two, because an Ella walk-in tub comes in both plain soaking and hydro massage configurations, so a deep warm soak and water jets can live in the same tub. For muscle and back discomfort, Ella's massage guide points to the hydro system, whose water jets are placed at the feet, calves, legs, hips and back, as explained in What type of walk-in tub is best for back pain relief?. If you are recovering from surgery, your physician's advice about warm water bathing and massage comes first, and this page helps you understand the options to discuss.

Please read this page as general educational information, not medical advice. Ella's Bubbles products and content are not intended to diagnose, cure or prevent any disease. For guidance about your own health, please talk with your doctor or a qualified healthcare professional.

Why This Is Not an Either-Or Choice

People usually picture two different products: a walk-in tub with a door and a seat on one side, and a deep jetted whirlpool on the other. In practice, the two things the phrase deep soaking whirlpool describes are a deep warm soak and water-powered jets, and both are available inside a walk-in tub. Hydro massage is the strong, traditional jetted-tub feeling: a water pump draws water from the tub and pushes it back through jets. A soaking configuration has no jets at all, so it gives you the warm bath without any massage system.

So the more useful question for a sore back is which configuration to choose. The sources we publish do not rate other manufacturers' tubs, so this page compares the configurations Ella builds and leaves the medical decision with your physician.

The Configurations Side by Side

ConfigurationWhat it doesFigures and controlsBest for
SoakingA warm bath with no jets and no massage systemnot listedA plain warm soak with nothing moving the water
Hydro massageA water pump recirculates bath water through jets at the feet, calves, legs, hips and backIntensity control dial; in-line heater runs with the pump; fill to 2 inches above the highest jets before startingMuscle and back discomfort, per Ella's massage guide
Air massageA separate blower pushes air through small jets in the seat and floorThree speeds; typical 4.5A 500W blower; Auto Purge runs 120 seconds about 20 minutes after the pump is offA gentler, bubbling, full body feel
Hydro and air togetherBoth systems in one tub, run separately or at the same timeSeparate controls for each systemA full spa experience with a choice of strong or gentle
MicrobubbleTiny bubbles cloud the water as a soaking and skin cleansing systemnot listedSkin care, since it is a soak and not a massage

What the differences mean for a back: only the hydro system puts water-powered jets on the back, and Ella's guidance is direct that for lower back pain the water-powered back jets are the system to choose. Air massage is much lighter, and some bathers describe it as a bubbling soak more than a massage. Microbubble is not a massage at all. A soaking tub gives warmth only. How hydro, air and microbubble combine goes deeper on pairing the systems, and the air bath guide explains the gentler option from button to bubbles.

What Deep Soaking Means in a Walk-In Tub

In a walk-in tub you soak seated, so depth is measured differently than in a tub you lie down in. The soaking depth video on this page explains that the soaking depth of a particular Ella tub is determined by three factors:

  • The measurement from the top of the seat to the center of the overflow.
  • The length of the seat.
  • The interior length of the tub.

The video also points out that the soaking depth depends on the size of the bather, so the same tub soaks two people differently. If warm water over your back is the goal, keep those three factors in mind as you compare models, and ask your Ella dealer or the team at (800) 480-6850 which models suit your height.

Making the Jets Gentle Enough for a Tender Back

A fair worry with chronic pain, and especially after surgery, is that jets will be too strong. Every hydro massage tub has an intensity control dial. It is an air control connected by a hose, not an electrical switch. Turning it up allows more air into the jet stream for a stronger feel, and turning it down reduces the air for a softer stream, all the way to barely perceptible. That lets you begin with the flow turned nearly all the way down and build up over several baths.

Two more details help a soak go well:

  • The in-line heater turns on with the hydro pump and helps hold your bath temperature while the jets run. It maintains warmth only and does not heat cold water, so fill the tub warm to begin with.
  • Only start the hydro massage after the water level is 2 inches above the highest jets, because running a water pump without enough water can permanently damage it.

An optional heated seat and backrest keeps you warm while the tub fills and drains. It is a comfort feature rather than a treatment, and it is welcome for anyone who dislikes sitting against a cool surface while the water rises.

Water Temperature, Soak Time and Your Physician

Ella's bathing guidance suggests warm water between 92 and 100 degrees Fahrenheit for about 20 minutes, kept warm rather than hot. The owner manuals warn that water temperature in excess of 100.4 degrees Fahrenheit may be harmful to your health, so check and adjust the temperature before you settle in. The warm-water bathing guidelines gather the full guidance, including shorter soaks for sensitive skin.

Our sources do not include guidance written for bathing after surgery, so that part of your question belongs with your surgeon or physician. Good things to ask them are whether warm water bathing is right for you yet, whether jets on your back are appropriate, and how warm and how long your soaks should be. Once you have that advice, the team at (800) 480-6850 can show you which models carry which therapy packages while you are still planning.

Video

Watch: How to Measure the Soaking Depth in Your Walk-In-Tub | Ellas Bubbles with chapters and a full transcript.

Video
Video
Video

Common Questions

Can a walk-in tub have both a deep soak and jets?
Yes. Ella walk-in tubs come in both plain soaking and hydro massage configurations, so a deep soak and water jets are not a choice between two different tubs. A hydro tub can also be enjoyed as a simple warm soak with the jets off.
Which massage system does Ella suggest for back pain?
Ella's massage guide suggests water jets for muscle or back pain because of their deep massaging properties. The hydro jets are placed at the feet, calves, legs, hips and back. Please follow your physician's advice about massage for your own condition.
Can I turn the hydro jets down for a sensitive back?
Yes. The intensity control dial softens or strengthens the flow by changing how much air enters the jet stream. Turned down, the stream becomes gentler, all the way to barely perceptible.
How warm should the water be for a back soak?
Ella's bathing guidance suggests warm water between 92 and 100 degrees Fahrenheit for about 20 minutes, kept warm rather than hot. The owner manuals warn that water above 100.4 degrees Fahrenheit may be harmful to your health. Follow your physician's advice if it differs.
Does the in-line heater warm up a cool bath?
No. The in-line heater turns on with the hydro pump and helps maintain your bath temperature while the jets run. It maintains warmth only and does not heat cold water, so fill the tub warm to begin with.
Is a walk-in tub safe to use after back surgery?
That is a question for your surgeon or physician, and our published guidance does not cover bathing after surgery. Ask them about warm water bathing, jets on your back, and how warm and how long to soak. This page is general educational information, not medical advice.

About this guide. Answers in the Ella's Bubbles Ella's Bubbles Walk-In Tub Support Center are compiled from real conversations with owners, our technicians’ notes and the product documentation, then reviewed by our team. Models and options have evolved over the years, so a detail here may differ slightly from yours. If something looks different on yours, send us your serial number and a specialist will confirm it for your model.

Was this helpful?

Did this solve your question?

If not, open a ticket and our team will pick it up from here.

Open a Support Ticket