Support Center / Door & Seal / Does an Inward Swing Walk-In Tub Door Leak Less Than an Outward Swing Door?
Back to Door & Seal

Does an Inward Swing Walk-In Tub Door Leak Less Than an Outward Swing Door?

No. On a level Ella walk-in tub neither door style leaks, so an inward swing door does not leak less than an outward swing door. Both close against the same kind of soft silicone gasket, and the only difference is what holds the door against it: the bath water on an inward door, and a gear and shaft driven lock on an outward door. Do walk-in bathtubs leak around the door or anywhere else? covers every place water can appear on a tub, while this page stays with the swing question and what it means when you choose a model.

Same Gasket, Two Ways of Holding It

The door seal, also called the door gasket, is the soft silicone strip around the door opening. When the door is closed and locked, the latch draws it evenly into the frame and the silicone compresses the same amount all the way around. That is true whichever way the door swings. What changes from one door to the next is the force that keeps that compression in place for the whole bath.

An inward swing door closes toward the bather and locks with a handle on the inside. The handle pulls the door into its seal, and as the tub starts to fill the water presses the door more firmly into place. The fuller the tub, the more firmly the door sits, so the door stays shut on its own while you soak. The same pressure is why an inward door will not open until the tub has drained completely, which is a safety feature and not a fault.

An outward swing door cannot borrow the water in that way, because the water pushes it toward the room. Ella's outward doors use a gear and shaft driven lock instead, with three latches on the U-shape door and two latches on the L-shape door, and the mechanism is built to withstand that same water pressure. The door video on this page shows all five Ella door styles in motion and describes the gear and shaft locking mechanism on the outward doors as the feature that gives them a tight seal.

The Five Door Families Side by Side

Each Ella model belongs to exactly one door family, and doors are not interchangeable, so you choose the swing by choosing the tub. The table lists what holds each door against its gasket, drawn from Ella's published door descriptions.

DoorSwingWhat holds it against the gasketModelsWhat it means for you
Brushed stainless steel doorInward, into the tubInterior chrome locking handle pulls it into the seal, and the filling water presses it tighterElite, Petite, Royal, Deluxe, Ultimate, Companion, EscapeNeeds no floor space in front of the tub; opens only after the tub has drained
S-shape acrylic doorInward, into the tubHandle on the inside; water pressure helps hold it shut once the tub fillsStandard, Standard60, Zen, Zen60, FlowSame water-assisted seal in a molded acrylic door
Ultra doorInward, into the tubHandle on the inside; water pressure helps hold it shut once the tub fillsUltraBrushed aluminum with frosted glass, removable for cleaning
U-shape outward doorOut into the room3-latch gear and shaft mechanism, handle on the outside faceCapri, Monaco, Front Entry, Mobile, Lounger, Shak, Big4One, Tub4Two, Big4TwoEasier entry and exit; needs clear floor in front of the door
L-shape outward doorOut into the room2-latch gear and shaft mechanism, handle on the outside faceTransfer familyExtra wide opening that can accommodate wheelchair users; requires 36 1/2 inches of clearance

Read down the third column and the pattern is clear. The three inward doors, whatever they are made of, use the bath water as part of the seal. The two outward doors rely on a mechanical lock that does the same job from the other direction. Neither approach is published as the more watertight one, and Ella does not rank one door as more or less leak-prone than another. Are Stainless Steel Walk-In Tub Doors Less Likely to Leak Than Acrylic Doors? makes the same point about door material. For your bathroom, the table is really a guide to floor space and entry, not to which door holds water.

What Really Puts Water at a Door

When water does appear at a door, the cause is almost always something other than the direction the door swings. Leveling is the number one cause. Every leveling leg must touch the floor and carry equal weight. A leg that has lost contact lets the frame warp, and the door no longer meets the seal evenly on one side. That is corrected at the leveling legs, not with a new gasket, and it applies to inward and outward doors alike.

The other usual reasons are just as independent of the swing:

  • Residue or soap film on the gasket, which keeps the silicone from pressing cleanly against the frame.
  • A plumbing union under the deck, which can be mistaken for a door leak.
  • A screw or hinge bolt that needs resealing.
  • Spray from the hand shower landing outside the tub.

Your installer confirms the door seal with a 20 minute fill as part of the warranty activation checklist, so a tub that passed that test and later shows water at the door has usually had something change underneath it. Check the legs first.

Drips After Draining Are Not a Leak

Outward doors have one habit that is easy to misread. When you open an outward swing door after a bath, water on the inside face of the door, in the gasket and on the sill runs down the frame and threshold, and it may leave a few drops on the bath mat. That is drainage, not a leak. The difference is timing: water on the door and frame after the tub is empty is expected, while water that runs steadily from the frame while the tub is full is a leak. If the floor stays dry while you soak, the seal is doing its job. Is It Normal for Water to Sit in the Door Frame After Draining? walks through that check. On an outward door, wait until the tub is empty before you rotate the handle, because opening early lets more water reach the frame than usual.

Choosing the Swing That Suits Your Bathroom

Since both doors seal, pick the swing for your space and your mobility. Inward swing doors need no floor space in front of the tub, so they suit small bathrooms and a nearby toilet. The bather steps in, stands, and closes the door past the knees, so some room inside the tub is needed, and it is easier to close and latch the door before you sit down. Does the stainless steel walk-in tub door only open inward? explains how that door is used.

Outward swing doors allow an easier entry and exit, and they need clear floor in front of the tub for the door to swing. The U-shape outward door swings 165 degrees. The L-shape door on the Transfer family swings 172 degrees, requires 36 1/2 inches of clearance, fits over a standard size toilet and has an extra wide opening that can accommodate wheelchair users. If the floor in front of the tub is tight, an inward model is the safer fit. If stepping in and turning to close a door is the hard part, an outward model is worth the floor space.

Keeping Either Seal Watertight

The gasket needs two things from you, whichever door you own: a clean surface to press against, and a rest when the tub is idle.

  • Clean the seal with a soft cloth and rubbing alcohol, never with abrasives.
  • Leave the door open or unlocked whenever the tub is not in use, so the seal is not compressed for days at a time.
  • Wipe the seal and frame after each bath to clear standing water and soap film.
  • Never lean on the door or use it as a handhold.
  • Make sure every leveling leg sits firmly on the floor.

A new seal sometimes arrives stuck or slightly flattened from shipping. That is normal, and squeezing the seal with your fingertips and pulling it away from the door frame restores its shape. If water still appears at the door while the tub is full, open a ticket at ellasbubbles.com/support or call (800) 480-6850 and the team will help you and your installer track it down.

Video

Watch: Pick the Perfect Walk-In Tub Door: 5 Elegant Door Options | Ella’s Bubbles with chapters and a full transcript.

Video
Video

Common Questions

Will an inward swing door open while the tub is still full?
No. Once the tub fills, the water presses an inward door into its seal, so it will not open until the tub has drained completely. That is a safety feature of the design and not a fault with the door.
How many latches hold an Ella outward swing door closed?
The U-shape outward door uses a 3-latch gear and shaft mechanism, and the L-shape outward door on the Transfer family uses a 2-latch gear and shaft mechanism. On both, the handle is on the outside face of the door and the lock pulls the door tight against the silicone gasket.
What is the most common reason water appears at a walk-in tub door?
A tub that is no longer level is the number one cause. A leveling leg that has lost contact with the floor lets the frame warp, so the door no longer meets the seal evenly. The fix is made at the leveling legs, not with a new gasket.
Is water in the door frame after draining a sign of a leak?
No, a little water on the frame and sill after draining is normal on an outward door. Water held on the inner face of the door and in the gasket runs down when the door opens. A leak is water that runs steadily from the frame while the tub is full.
Can I swap my inward door for an outward door later?
No. Doors are not interchangeable, so the swing direction comes with the model you choose. The Monaco, for example, is the Royal's outward counterpart at the same size, and the Transfer family is outward only.

About this guide. Answers in the Ella's Bubbles Ella's Bubbles Walk-In Tub Support Center are compiled from real conversations with owners, our technicians’ notes and the product documentation, then reviewed by our team. Models and options have evolved over the years, so a detail here may differ slightly from yours. If something looks different on yours, send us your serial number and a specialist will confirm it for your model.

Was this helpful?

Did this solve your question?

If not, open a ticket and our team will pick it up from here.

Open a Support Ticket