Support Center / Walk-In Tub Models / How Does a Walk-In Tub Compare to a Regular Tub or Shower?
Back to Walk-In Tub Models

How Does a Walk-In Tub Compare to a Regular Tub or Shower?

A walk-in tub has a sealed door and a built-in seat, so you step in over a low threshold, close the door, fill, bathe, drain and then step out, instead of climbing over a high wall into an open basin. A walk-in shower also has a low step-in entry, but it suits someone who can still stand or needs only a little assistance, and it does not include the seating a walk-in tub has. Ella's Bubbles offers both, as outlined in What Products Does Ella's Bubbles Offer?, and a walk-in tub can also be set up for showering.

Walk-In Tub Versus a Regular Bathtub

A regular bathtub is an open basin. You lift a leg over the wall to get in, lower yourself to the floor of the tub, and reverse all of that to get out. A walk-in tub changes each of those moments.

  • The entry. You step through a door over a low threshold. The Capri, for example, has a 3.5 inch threshold, far lower than the wall of a standard tub.
  • The seat. A built-in seat sits at a comfortable height, so the bather sits down instead of lowering to the floor of the tub.
  • The supports. Grab bars, a watertight door, a fast-fill faucet and gravity drains are designed to work together.
  • The order of the bath. Because the door is part of the tub wall, you sit inside while the tub fills and again while it drains. You step in, close the door, fill, bathe, drain and then step out.
  • The therapies. A conventional tub simply holds water. Many Ella models are equipped with jets, and the jet count and pump setup depend on the model and the therapy package. Optional hydro massage, air massage, a heated seat and chromatherapy are available for a therapeutic soak.

Filling and draining are built for that seated wait. The Ella faucet system is capable of a fill rate of about 16 gallons per minute. The tubs drain by gravity with no drain pump, and a dual drain model connected to a proper 2 inch drain line typically empties in two minutes or less. The number of drains varies by model, so confirm the drain setup on the spec sheet for the tub you choose.

Walk-In Tub Versus a Walk-In Shower

A walk-in shower shares the biggest benefit of a walk-in tub, the low step-in entry. The difference is what happens after you step in. A shower is for standing, so it suits someone who can still stand or needs only a little assistance. It does not include the seating a walk-in tub has, although certain models have a shower seat. A walk-in tub is built around the seat, and it adds the option of a deep, warm soak and massage that a shower cannot give.

Ella's shower stalls, multi-piece kits and barrier-free roll-in bases are built with a fiberglass reinforced shell and the AcrylX finish, and the walls are reinforced on all sides so grab bars and seats can be mounted anywhere on the wall. That matters when a bather's needs change after the shower is in. The surface itself is described in What is AcrylX, and how does it compare to regular acrylic?.

The Three Options Side by Side

The table sets the options next to each other using figures from Ella's published material. Where a figure is not published, the cell says not listed.

OptionHow you get inSeatingPublished figuresBest for
Walk-in tubThrough a sealed door over a low thresholdBuilt-in seat3.5 inch threshold on the Capri. Fill rate of about 16 gallons per minute. Dual 2 inch gravity drains typically empty in two minutes or less.A seated, supported soak, with optional massage
Regular bathtubOver a high wall into an open basinNone. You lower to the floor of the tub.Not listedA bather who is comfortable climbing in and sitting low
Walk-in showerLow step-in entryNot included, although certain models have a shower seatNot listedSomeone who can still stand or needs only a little assistance
Walk-in tub with a screen and shower columnThrough the same sealed doorBuilt-in seat, so you can shower seated or standing4-fold glass screen 44 inches wide by 42 inches highA household that wants both a bath and a shower in one fixture

What the differences mean for you: the choice comes down to how you want to bathe and how steady you feel on your feet. If stepping over a tub wall is the worry and you still want to soak, the walk-in tub answers both. If you prefer to stand and rinse and only need a low entry, a walk-in shower is the simpler fit. If the home has people with different needs, a walk-in tub with a screen and a shower column covers both ways of bathing in one space.

Can You Shower in a Walk-In Tub, and Can You Add a Shower?

Yes to both. A tempered glass screen keeps water off the floor, and a deck mounted shower column lets you shower seated or standing in the tub.

The video on this page shows how the shower column kit is added. It connects to an Ella 2-piece or 5-piece fast-fill faucet set. The installer removes the existing hand shower, installs the shower column base attachment into the vacant receptacle, replaces the water supply line, and attaches the new one-half inch supply line to the diverter on the faucet set. After that, the shower column is ready for use.

For the screen, every seated Ella walk-in tub takes the 4-fold tempered glass shower screen. It is 44 inches wide by 42 inches high, mounts to the wall and not to the tub, and folds back out of the way when you finish. The LayDown tubs take their own bi-fold screen, and a plain shower curtain fits any Ella tub. Ella does not currently offer a walk-in tub with a full glass door in place of a folding screen. The right match for each situation is in Which shower screen or curtain fits your Ella walk-in tub model?.

Will a Walk-In Tub Fit Where My Regular Tub Is Now?

In most homes, yes. Many walk-in tubs are surprisingly compact and fit into the space taken up by a typical bathtub. Most Ella walk-in tubs go into the same three-wall alcove your current tub occupies, so you keep the room's layout and plumbing locations. When the tub is shorter than the alcove, an extension panel fills the gap.

Two things are worth knowing before you plan the swap. Ella tubs use their own deck-mount faucet packages, so your existing tub spout and handles are normally replaced, not reused. And a regular bathtub cannot be turned into a walk-in tub by Ella. The door, seal, frame and threshold of a walk-in tub are engineered together, which is why Ella builds complete tubs only, as Can Ella Cut a Walk-Through Opening or Add a Door to My Existing Bathtub? explains.

Your Ella dealer or the team at (800) 480-6850 will be happy to help you weigh a tub against a shower for your bathroom. Bring your alcove measurements and a note of who will use it and how they like to bathe.

Video

Watch: Easy Shower Column Installation for Your Walk-In Tub | Ella’s Bubbles with chapters and a full transcript.

Video
Video
Video

Common Questions

Can you take a shower in a walk-in tub?
Yes. A tempered glass screen keeps water off the floor, and a deck mounted shower column lets you shower seated or standing in the tub. A plain shower curtain also fits any Ella tub.
Can a shower be added to a walk-in tub later?
Yes, the shower column kit connects to an Ella 2-piece or 5-piece fast-fill faucet set. It installs on the tub deck in place of the existing hand shower, with a new one-half inch supply line attached to the faucet diverter. A local licensed plumber can make the connection.
What is the main difference between a walk-in tub and a regular tub?
A walk-in tub has a sealed door and a built-in seat. You step in over a low threshold, close the door, fill, bathe, drain and then step out. A regular tub is an open basin that you climb into over a high wall.
Is a walk-in shower or a walk-in tub better for me?
A walk-in shower suits someone who can still stand or needs only a little assistance. A walk-in tub is built around a seat and offers a soak, with optional massage therapies. A walk-in tub with a screen and shower column gives you both.
How long does a walk-in tub take to drain?
Ella tubs drain by gravity with no drain pump. A dual drain model connected to a proper 2 inch drain line typically empties in two minutes or less. The number of drains varies by model, so check the spec sheet for your tub.
Will a walk-in tub fit in my existing bathtub space?
Most Ella walk-in tubs go into the same three-wall alcove a current tub occupies. When the tub is shorter than the alcove, an extension panel fills the gap. Measure your alcove and compare it with the actual size on the spec sheet.

About this guide. Answers in the Ella's Bubbles Ella's Bubbles Walk-In Tub Support Center are compiled from real conversations with owners, our technicians’ notes and the product documentation, then reviewed by our team. Models and options have evolved over the years, so a detail here may differ slightly from yours. If something looks different on yours, send us your serial number and a specialist will confirm it for your model.

Was this helpful?

Did this solve your question?

If not, open a ticket and our team will pick it up from here.

Open a Support Ticket